US Home building slump

US incentive programs for home buyers have expired and it looks like the real estate industry hasn’t got enough momentum to lift the US economy. Even with rock-bottom interest rates the industry is slumping.

WASHINGTON – Homebuilders are sending a message: They won’t be able to contribute much to the economic recovery now that government home-buying incentives have vanished.

Home construction and applications for building permits sank in May, overshadowing favorable reports on manufacturing and wholesale inflation.

Fewer homes mean fewer jobs. Construction fuels a broad swath of industries across the economy. Yet double-digit unemployment is among the main reasons people have passed on buying new homes.

The solution is simple. Government must take on more debt and pour more stimulus dollars into the economy, then the problem will be solved and everyone can get back to living the good life.

116 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
SuperSmartBull
SuperSmartBull
10 years ago

Uh oh, Germany lose to Serbia in FIFA hi-fi. They will not be in buying mood, good time to snap up B&B properties in the interior of BC. Then can flip for big cash when Germany beats Ghana. See bears, lots of money making opportunities. You too can be so damn rich.

Boombust
Boombust
10 years ago

"http://www.realtor.ca/property…..Id=9530645

http://www.realtor.ca/property…..Id=9563285…&…

I'll take the cheaper one IF I want to move to Abbotsford, the vendor cuts the price even more, IF I can get a good mortgage rate and IF the seller will throw in some upgrades…ain't selling FUN!

patriotz
10 years ago

@Keeping an Eye on The Pimps: The start of each year is prime time for economic pessimists, who try to persuade us terrible things are about to happen. A perennial favorite is the "housing bubble" about to burst, with a supposedly devastating impact on household wealth. This has been repeatedly recycled since June 2002 by bearish economic forecasters like Ed Leamer of University of California-Los Angeles and Stephen Roach of Morgan Stanley. And the same scary story has proven handy for policy wonks who abuse it to rationalize their agendas, such as lecturing the Fed to keep interest rates too low or lecturing Congress to push tax rates too high. Although the overworked analogy between housing and tech stocks sounds dramatic, it is quite preposterous. "The downside of this [housing] bubble," said Mr. Roach last month, is "potentially far worse… Read more »

Keeping an Eye on Th
Keeping an Eye on Th
10 years ago

No bubbles please, we are Canadian.

http://www.montrealgazette.com/business/Canada+ho

"This mythical creature terrorized credulous analysts and journalists in recent months, only a short while after some of these same unhappy people had been shaken by the equally nonexistent Canadian housing-market collapse."

Just be prepared to read a lot of these pumper stories frequently for a while.

A fine balancing act, they can't deny the slowdown, but they will apply the lipstick to the pig- it good to slow a little leg to the advertisers.

"A-sharp"
"A-sharp"
10 years ago

@Recently bearish: I've been watching my local market intently. It is conservative to say that the local condo market is very competitive. It is without exaggeration that I say that the condo market price here on average is 20% below peak (2008). This is especially true in the new condo market. What do you do when the developer undercuts you? These units were in the mid to high two's on presale. Here is an example of a flipper trying to get his initial money and costs out (including RE fees), and the next example is a the new lower pricing for the building from the developer. http://www.realtor.ca/propertyDetails.aspx?proper… http://www.realtor.ca/propertyDetails.aspx?proper… These two units are not exactly comparables, but I can tell you that the difference is only Sq ft related. I've walked through and this is the worst of the worst spec… Read more »

patriotz
10 years ago

@space889:

Maybe there are a lot of people who paid off mortgage but have re-fi their homes via home equity line of credit? Maybe those people count as mortgage free in the stats?

Any loan secured by the equity on real estate is a mortgage by definition. Some people might not call a HELOC a mortgage, but I guarantee that's what it says on the land title.

There really are a lot of people who have paid for houses. For example, remember that up until very recently all retirees were pre-boomers and had quaint values such as believing you should pay off your house in 25 years.

Also remember that Canada-wide (or US-wide) statistics include places where houses historically have been cheap or have been passed down within families.

Anonymous
Anonymous
10 years ago

@Newcomer:

"If this is an investment, you are missing some costs, "

I'm talking about a primary residence.

Anonymous
Anonymous
10 years ago

@Tony Danza:

"You’re analysis is worth less than nothing."

With a grammar mistake like that the rest of your words are worth less than nothing.

Try actually doing the numbers, rather than just whining about them, and come back when you have something to add to the debate.

Jimmy
Jimmy
10 years ago

#104 grimreaper Says:

June 17th, 2010 at 9:14 pm

@Tony Danza: That’s funny coming from a retard bear who been wrong for more than a decade. Rent is due in 13 days.

——————————————-

What's wrong with paying rent in 13 days?

Unless you are mortgage free, your mortgage payment is also due in 13 days……also, have you put money aside each month for property taxes, roof repair, blown water tank (and if it's a condo you have, special assessment), etc….

jesse
10 years ago

Oops I meant 179 sales. 179 for the month would put sales at around 3900. To put that in perspective, 3800 is the MINIMUM required to stave off month-over-month price drops with current inventory levels.

At best it's not bearish but hardly bullish.

jesse
10 years ago

@paulb.: So 179 listings is bullish? LOL

most_interesting_man
most_interesting_man
10 years ago

Well I'm the most interesting man in the world and when I drink beer I choose Dos Equis. And when I chose where to live I choose to own a condo in Vancouver.

grimreaper
grimreaper
10 years ago

@Tony Danza: That's funny coming from a retard bear who been wrong for more than a decade. Rent is due in 13 days.

McLovin
McLovin
10 years ago

:

Sorry, but I coined the term ‘Realturd’ a couple of years ago on Garth’s blog and had it copywriten too. You therefore can’t use the term ‘Realturd’ without my written permission. You may consider calling them ‘Fucksticks’ instead.

Oh, hell, just keep calling them realturds!!

Sorry Chilled, I read it somewhere, might have been Garth's blog and having been using it ever since. I can't think a more perfect term!

Newcomer
Newcomer
10 years ago

@Anoymous: If this is an investment, you are missing some costs, and it is ridiculous to assume such low interest rates over the life of the loan but, even if your calculations were right, that would not be an argument against a 50% drop. What you are saying is that, if interest rates state at historic lows, and rents stay at historic highs then, after a 50% drop it would be a good buying opportunity. Who here is disputing that. Prices would probably go up under those conditions. Prices overshoot on the way down. I don't know how old you are, but I think there is a good possibility that you have never seen a normal market where investors buy RE and rent it out because that gives them a couple hundred bucks a month while the mortgage is being… Read more »

Recently bearish
Recently bearish
10 years ago

The past two weeks I've been looking daily at listed prices vs. sale prices for every sale in Vancouver (East and West). Didn't keep track of specific numbers, but would estimate 80% of the properties sell under listed price, 5% sell over and 15% sell for asking. Most sales are 5-10% under asking, but some have greater reductions than that. Certainly a different market than last fall or earlier this spring.

Chilled
Chilled
10 years ago

@McLovin:

Sorry, but I coined the term 'Realturd' a couple of years ago on Garth's blog and had it copywriten too. You therefore can't use the term 'Realturd' without my written permission. You may consider calling them 'Fucksticks' instead.

Oh, hell, just keep calling them realturds!!

nonymouse
nonymouse
10 years ago

75

Thanks for finding such a good example. ALthough current asking rent seems on the high side I think that in your end scenario a $1200-1300 monthly payments seems pretty reasonable. Now we just have to wait for that 50 percent discount…

mattymatt
mattymatt
10 years ago

:

oops…It's been 2 years since I sold my place… I totally forgot about that. Thanks for the reminder. (and I was so excited…)

trackback

[…] 17 June 2010 · Leave a Comment We love the paradox of ‘Below Market Value!’. Whatever this sells for IS market value. Prices are dropping. -vreaa [Hat-tip to Teddy Bear at vancouvercondo.info 17 Jun 2010 9:13 am] […]

Tony Danza
Tony Danza
10 years ago

@Anoymous: Is your real name Samantha? Are you currently sipping a "cranteeny"?

How about you take your tired old arguments that have been discredited on this blog for the past 3 years and head on over to the zoo that houses the rest of your realtor buddies.

Tony Danza
Tony Danza
10 years ago

@Anoymous: Why would I even bother to look at the rest of your numbers when you can't even copy the first number correctly? You're analysis is worth less than nothing.

Anonymous
Anonymous
10 years ago

@mattymatt:

You don't understand how sales work. Places are sold and then it takes 2-3 weeks and sometimes longer for the sale to go through. Sales happening today means they were actually transacted some time ago.

There is too much noise and varience simply looking at daily stats.

mattymatt
mattymatt
10 years ago

Here is why there is larger # of sales today. Yesterday, mainstream media has finally agreed that house prices are dropping and will continue to drop. So, a house listed for $700k probably sold today for $640k. (panicky investor brakes even) Somebody thinks they got a deal! They just set the new high for listing a house in that neighbourhood. Love it!

Anoymous
Anoymous
10 years ago

@jim:

"what you are missing is that historically when RE prices correct rents fall as well. Prove it you say? look to the south now"

I've not heard anybody, not even bears, say that Vancouver rents are "out of whack with fundamentals".