CMHC and the rental housing market

Over at the The Star, our mayor has helped to write an opinion piece asking that the CMHC provide more loans for rental housing construction:

For most of us, housing is our biggest expense. One out of every five dollars we earn goes to build, buy, rent and run our homes. Facing high home prices, large personal debts, and an uncertain economy, fewer Canadians can buy a new home today than in the past, and they are choosing to rent instead.

Unfortunately, in many cities finding an affordable place to rent is nearly impossible. The most immediate problem is supply. Vacancy rates under 3 per cent push rents up. In Vancouver and the Greater Toronto Area, it’s 1.4 per cent.

Vacancy rates this low force our young people to move out of the city, threaten seniors on fixed incomes, and have a negative impact on local businesses.

That’s why this spring’s federal budget must put Canada’s rental housing market on solid ground, by pursuing low-cost, high-leverage policies that get jobs on the ground and build housing Canadians can afford.

It’s like magic, creating jobs and homes.  What could go wrong with a ‘low-cost, high-leverage’ policy like that?

Click here to view all comments chronologically

67 Responses to “CMHC and the rental housing market”

Pages: [2] 1 » Show All

  1. 67
  2. b5baxter Says: Reply to this comment

    @Many Franks:

    We have crossed the line. I will post an updated graph on Thursday.

    Welcome to the highest inventory in the past 7 years.

    Current score: 9
  3. 66
  4. SoundandFury Says: Reply to this comment

    @SoundandFury: If anybody was wondering about the low price for strata lot 62, it is a tenants in common situation. $149,450 is a 50% share; the selling price was twice that.

    Current score: 0
  5. 65
  6. Tick Tock Says: Reply to this comment

    RE the District… looks like some big price cuts are a coming, think Walmart rolling back prices! Seems to me 40% of the complex is for sale… more than likely soon to be 50%

    Current score: 15
  7. 64
  8. Anonymous Says: Reply to this comment

    Regarding rental shopping on craigslist: I’ve found two places through craigslist ads, and BOTH of them I negotiated rent down on. One was a small house near Main and 25th, the other a 2bd+ den apartment in Kits. Got a hundred bucks off the monthly rent on both without trying too hard.

    If you’re a good tenant it’s not tough to call their bluff on craigslist. Most of them are asking too much and you’re a sucker if you offer them asking price (unless it’s already a good deal).

    Current score: 12
  9. 63
  10. Yaya Says: Reply to this comment

    @Makaya: It’s gorgeous! Is that an extension cord hanging from a coat hanger over the living room window?

    Current score: 9
  11. 62
  12. Makaya Makaya Says: Reply to this comment

    @chilled: just one question: who reads the Tyee?

    On a lighter note, I wish I was not already renting a place, otherwise I would have jumped on this fantastic 2BR furnished basement in Burnaby… don’t you like the red carpet and the matching sofas?

    All of it for the bargain price of $1200/month. What a deal!

    http://vancouver.en.craigslist.ca/bnc/apa/2879396545.html

    Current score: 15
  13. 61
  14. chilled chilled Says: Reply to this comment

    @Anonymous:

    “The Tyee gets most of its funding from unions affiliated with the BC Federation of Labour and works closely with the massive US Eco group the Tides Foundation, which has funneled tens of millions of dollars into groups against the oil sands and, incidentally, helped fund the mayoral campaign of Gregor Robertson.

    It may be a useful article but it always helps to know where they’re coming from.”

    And not generally agreeing with The Tyee doesn’t make one “right wing” as anonymous #1 accused me of. I just can’t stand the idiotic articles and political correctness.

    Current score: 3
  15. 60
  16. SoundandFury Says: Reply to this comment

    @ZRH2YVR
    Re: The District selling prices
    “SL” is the strata lot number. “Declared” is the declared value when registered with LTO. The 19 units where the declared value is blank are still owned by the developer.

    SL  REGISTERED DECLARED  ADDRESS
    --- ---------- --------- -------------------------
    1   Feb 28, 12 $321,900
    2   Mar 08, 12 $321,900
    3   Feb 27, 12 $374,900
    4   Feb 28, 12 $379,900
    5   Feb 27, 12 $379,900
    6   Feb 28, 12 $349,900 204-233 E. 7TH AVENUE
    7   Mar 05, 12 $329,900 231 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    8   Feb 28, 12 $299,900 201-251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    9   Mar 05, 12 $314,900
    10  Mar 08, 12 $314,900 203 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    11  Mar 08, 12 $311,900
    12  Feb 27, 12 $311,900 #205 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENU
    13  Feb 24, 12 $329,900 206 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    14  Feb 29, 12 $299,900
    15  Mar 08, 12 $309,900 302 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    16  Feb 29, 12 $300,000 #303 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENU
    17  Mar 08, 12 $314,900
    18  Feb 27, 12 $319,900 #305 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENU
    19  Feb 28, 12 $334,900 306 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    20  Feb 29, 12 $429,900 #401 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENU
    21  Feb 28, 12 $309,900
    22  Feb 27, 12 $284,900 #454-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    23  Feb 27, 12 $289,900 #404 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENU
    24  Mar 02, 12 $289,900
    25  Feb 28, 12 $279,900
    26  Feb 28, 12 $319,900
    27  Feb 27, 12 $469,900 408 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    28  Feb 24, 12 $314,900 409 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    29  Feb 28, 12 $314,900 #410 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENU
    30  Feb 29, 12 $324,900 411 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    31  Feb 01, 12
    32  Mar 08, 12 $317,900
    33  Feb 27, 12 $327,900 415 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    34  Feb 27, 12 $419,900 501-251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    35  Mar 06, 12 $312,900
    36  Feb 28, 12 $287,900
    37  Feb 28, 12 $292,900 504 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    38  Feb 01, 12
    39  Feb 28, 12 $282,900
    40  Mar 07, 12 $332,900 903 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    41  Feb 29, 12 $449,900 508 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    42  Feb 24, 12 $332,900 509 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    43  Feb 01, 12
    44  Feb 01, 12
    45  Feb 24, 12 $322,900
    46  Feb 27, 12 $414,900 11622 97TH AVENUE
    47  Feb 24, 12 $325,900 602-251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    48  Feb 24, 12 $290,900
    49  Feb 28, 12 $295,900 604-251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    50  Feb 27, 12 $295,900
    51  Mar 01, 12 $285,900
    52  Feb 28, 12 $335,900
    53  Feb 28, 12 $454,900 #608 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENU
    54  Mar 02, 12 $335,900 #609-251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    55  Feb 28, 12 $404,900 610 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    56  Feb 27, 12 $223,900
    57  Mar 08, 12 $386,650
    58  Feb 24, 12 $325,900 613 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    59  Feb 28, 12 $429,900 #701 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENU
    60  Mar 02, 12 $318,900
    61  Feb 28, 12 $293,900
    62  Feb 28, 12 $149,450
    63  Feb 01, 12
    64  Feb 24, 12 $288,900 706 251 EAST 7TH AVE.
    65  Feb 28, 12 $338,900 707 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    66  Feb 28, 12 $459,900 708 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    67  Feb 27, 12 $338,900 709 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    68  Mar 02, 12 $419,900 710 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    69  Feb 01, 12
    70  Feb 28, 12 $389,900 712 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    71  Feb 24, 12 $328,900 713 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    72  Feb 24, 12 $434,900
    73  Feb 01, 12
    74  Feb 28, 12 $296,900 803-251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    75  Feb 28, 12 $301,900 804 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    76  Feb 27, 12 $301,900
    77  Feb 28, 12 $291,900 #806 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENU
    78  Feb 29, 12 $341,900 807 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    79  Feb 27, 12 $464,900 808 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    80  Feb 28, 12 $341,900 #809 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENU
    81  Feb 01, 12
    82  Feb 28, 12 $227,900
    83  Feb 27, 12 $394,900
    84  Feb 27, 12 $331,900 813 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    85  Feb 28, 12 $429,900
    86  Feb 28, 12 $331,400 902 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    87  Feb 01, 12
    88  Feb 27, 12 $304,900
    89  Feb 28, 12 $304,900
    90  Feb 28, 12 $294,900
    91  Feb 28, 12 $344,900 #907, 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    92  Feb 27, 12 $469,900 908 251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    93  Feb 27, 12 $344,900
    94  Feb 01, 12
    95  Feb 28, 12 $229,900
    96  Feb 27, 12 $399,900
    97  Feb 28, 12 $334,900
    98  Feb 27, 12 $649,900 1001-251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    99  Feb 27, 12 $699,900 1002 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENU
    100 Feb 29, 12 $549,900
    101 Mar 06, 12 $849,900 1004 - 251 EAST 7TH AVENU
    102 Feb 28, 12 $799,900
    103 Feb 28, 12 $559,900 1006-251 EAST 7TH AVENUE
    104 Feb 01, 12
    105 Mar 06, 12 $379,900
    106 Feb 27, 12 $379,900
    107 Feb 28, 12 $379,900
    108 Feb 28, 12 $359,900 710 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    109 Feb 28, 12 $350,625 264 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    110 Feb 01, 12
    111 Feb 27, 12 $349,900 270 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    112 Feb 28, 12 $449,900 #151 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    113 Feb 28, 12 $314,900 152 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    114 Feb 28, 12 $324,900 153 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    115 Feb 27, 12 $449,900 154 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    116 Feb 27, 12 $319,900 155 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    117 Feb 01, 12
    118 Feb 27, 12 $324,900
    119 Feb 27, 12 $439,900 251 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    120 Feb 27, 12 $304,900 #252-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    121 Feb 27, 12 $329,900
    122 Feb 24, 12 $439,900 254 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    123 Feb 24, 12 $283,900 255 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    124 Mar 06, 12 $399,900 256 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    125 Mar 01, 12 $313,900
    126 Feb 27, 12 $319,900 258 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    127 Feb 29, 12 $319,900 #259 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    128 Feb 27, 12 $314,900
    129 Mar 07, 12 $314,900 210-250 EAST 6TH STREET
    130 Feb 29, 12 $274,900
    131 Feb 28, 12 $354,900 352 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    132 Feb 27, 12 $303,900
    133 Feb 27, 12 $313,900 354-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    134 Feb 28, 12 $313,900 #355 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    135 Feb 27, 12 $313,900 356 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    136 Feb 27, 12 $313,900 #357-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    137 Feb 28, 12 $273,900 #358 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    138 Feb 28, 12 $258,900 359 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    139 Mar 06, 12 $268,900
    140 Feb 28, 12 $449,900 #361 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    141 Feb 27, 12 $314,900
    142 Feb 28, 12 $339,900
    143 Feb 28, 12 $449,900 #364 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    144 Feb 01, 12
    145 Feb 27, 12 $402,900
    146 Mar 06, 12 $321,900
    147 Feb 28, 12 $324,900 #368 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    148 Feb 28, 12 $324,900
    149 Feb 27, 12 $304,900
    150 Mar 07, 12 $304,900
    151 Feb 27, 12 $304,900 #372 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    152 Feb 29, 12 $289,900 373-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    153 Mar 01, 12 $279,900 451 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    154 Mar 08, 12 $357,900 452-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    155 Feb 28, 12 $306,900 453 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    156 Feb 28, 12 $316,900 #454-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    157 Feb 27, 12 $316,900 #455 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    158 Feb 28, 12 $316,900 456-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    159 Feb 27, 12 $316,900
    160 Feb 28, 12 $268,900
    161 Mar 05, 12 $273,900
    162 Feb 28, 12 $268,900
    163 Mar 02, 12 $359,900 461 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    164 Feb 27, 12 $279,900 462 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    165 Feb 28, 12 $299,900 463 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    166 Feb 24, 12 $369,900
    167 Feb 27, 12 $289,900
    168 Feb 28, 12 $405,900 466 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    169 Feb 27, 12 $329,900
    170 Mar 06, 12 $349,000 #468, 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    171 Feb 28, 12 $329,900 469 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    172 Feb 27, 12 $314,900
    173 Feb 28, 12 $314,900 #471 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    174 Feb 27, 12 $314,900
    175 Mar 08, 12 $294,900
    176 Feb 29, 12 $284,900
    177 Feb 27, 12 $360,900
    178 Feb 29, 12 $309,900 503-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    179 Feb 28, 12 $319,900 #504 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    180 Feb 28, 12 $319,900
    181 Feb 28, 12 $319,900
    182 Feb 24, 12 $319,900
    183 Feb 28, 12 $270,900
    184 Mar 08, 12 $265,900
    185 Feb 28, 12 $479,900 510 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    186 Feb 28, 12 $349,900 511-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    187 Feb 28, 12 $410,900 512 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    188 Feb 28, 12 $332,900 513 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    189 Mar 06, 12 $524,900 #514 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    190 Feb 28, 12 $549,900 #515, 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    191 Feb 28, 12 $324,900 #516, 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    192 Feb 28, 12 $299,900 517 250 EAST 6TH AVE.
    193 Feb 28, 12 $289,900
    194 Feb 27, 12 $363,900
    195 Feb 28, 12 $315,299
    196 Feb 27, 12 $343,900 604 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    197 Feb 29, 12 $346,345 #605-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    198 Feb 01, 12
    199 Feb 27, 12 $328,900
    200 Feb 27, 12 $287,900
    201 Mar 05, 12 $287,900 609 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    202 Feb 28, 12 $439,900 610 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    203 Feb 28, 12 $299,900 #611-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    204 Feb 28, 12 $415,900 #612-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    205 Feb 01, 12
    206 Feb 28, 12 $414,900 #614 - 250 6TH AVE. E.
    207 Feb 24, 12 $223,900
    208 Feb 28, 12 $424,900 616 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    209 Feb 28, 12 $334,900
    210 Feb 24, 12 $304,900 618 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    211 Feb 28, 12 $294,900
    212 Feb 28, 12 $366,900 702 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    213 Feb 27, 12 $331,900
    214 Feb 27, 12 $346,900
    215 Feb 27, 12 $346,900 705 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    216 Feb 28, 12 $346,900
    217 Feb 28, 12 $346,900 707 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    218 Feb 27, 12 $289,900 708 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    219 Feb 01, 12
    220 Feb 24, 12 $444,900 710-250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    221 Feb 28, 12 $302,900 #711, 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    222 Mar 02, 12 $420,900
    223 Feb 28, 12 $338,900
    224 Feb 01, 12
    225 Mar 07, 12 $237,900
    226 Feb 28, 12 $429,900
    227 Feb 28, 12 $344,900
    228 Feb 27, 12 $309,900
    229 Feb 27, 12 $299,900 801 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    230 Feb 24, 12 $369,900
    231 Feb 28, 12 $334,900 #803 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    232 Feb 24, 12 $349,900 804 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    233 Feb 27, 12 $349,900
    234 Feb 27, 12 $349,900 #806 - 250 6TH AVE., E.
    235 Mar 08, 12 $349,900 #807 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    236 Mar 08, 12 $292,900 #808 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    237 Feb 24, 12 $479,900 809 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    238 Feb 28, 12 $305,900
    239 Feb 28, 12 $425,900
    240 Feb 27, 12 $341,900
    241 Feb 28, 12 $424,900 # 813 - 250 EAST 6TH AVEN
    242 Feb 27, 12 $227,900
    243 Feb 24, 12 $434,900 815 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENUE
    244 Feb 27, 12 $349,900
    245 Feb 28, 12 $314,900 #817 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    246 Feb 01, 12
    247 Mar 07, 12 $799,900
    248 Mar 08, 12 $599,900 #903 - 250 6TH AVE., E.
    249 Feb 24, 12 $799,900 #904 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    250 Feb 28, 12 $799,900 #905 - 250 EAST 6TH AVENU
    251 Feb 27, 12 $649,900

    Current score: 18
  17. 59
  18. chilled chilled Says: Reply to this comment

    @Anonymous:

    Wrong. Completely wrong and you missed my point.

    The Tyee has spent years writing from one slant and banned any dissenting opinion.

    For example, find ONE article in The Tyee archives critical of Canada’s Immigration Policies, overly generous refugee system, et al. You won’t. And if you presented a dissenting opinion, ON ANYTHING > banned. I know.

    Now these snot nosed journalism wannabees are crying about what happened to the housing market. Political ideology aside, it’s muddied thinking as found in The Tyee THAT GOT US IN THIS MESS AND IT IS TOO FUCKING LATE TO COMPLAIN, especially from them.

    Current score: -2
  19. 58
  20. Turkey Says: Reply to this comment

    @Anonymous: And everything the Tyee publishes is personally pre-masticated by George Soros himself, don’t you know.

    Seriously, what’s with the Tides/Vision fixation some people have?

    Current score: 7
  21. 57
  22. good-format Says: Reply to this comment

    Copied from PaulB’s number
    http://www.laurenandpaul.ca

     Date      Listing  Price(+-)  Sold   Inv     Inv(+-)  S/L(%)
    Mar 01       313      94       123   14,912      5     39.3 
    Mar 02       251      97       163   14,919      7     64.9
    
    Mar 05       338     134       118   15,069    150     34.9
    Mar 06       298     114       163   15,161     92     54.7
    Mar-07       260     114        71   15,305    144     27.3
    Mar-08       237     106       152   15,345     40     64.1
    Mar-09       229      76        69   15,454    109     30.1
    
    Mar-12       306     119       120   15,588    134     39.2
    
    Total-Cur  2,232     854       979             790     43.9
    5 day-avg    266     106       115             104     43.2
    Total-Est  5,956   2,335     2,589   17,041  2,134     43.5
    

    Historical March Sold and listing

    Year    Sold   Listing  S/L(%)
    2001    2,315   3,805   60.8
    2002    3,392   5,168   65.6
    2003    3,304   4,272   77.3
    2004    4,371   5,709   76.6
    2005    3,938   5,083   77.5
    2006    4,033   5,767   69.9
    2007    3,582   5,456   65.7
    2008    2,997   5,674   52.8
    2009    2,265   4,385   51.7
    2010    3,137   7,004   44.8
    2011    4,080   6,797   60.0
    
    Avg     3,401   5,375   63.3
    Median  3,392   5,456   65.6
    

    Current score: 22
  23. 56
  24. Makaya Makaya Says: Reply to this comment

    @Makaya: 134!

    Current score: 8
  25. 55
  26. Makaya Makaya Says: Reply to this comment

    @good-format: Inventory went up by 135 today ;)

    Current score: 7
  27. 54
  28. good-format Says: Reply to this comment

    Copied from PaulB’s number
    http://www.laurenandpaul.ca

     Date      Listing  Price(+-)  Sold   Inv     Inv(+-)  S/L(%)
    Mar 01       313      94       123   14,912      5     39.3 
    Mar 02       251      97       163   14,919      7     64.9
    
    Mar 05       338     134       118   15,069    150     34.9
    Mar 06       298     114       163   15,161     92     54.7
    Mar-07       260     114        71   15,305    144     27.3
    Mar-08       237     106       152   15,345     40     64.1
    Mar-09       229      76        69   15,454    109     30.1
    
    Mar-12       306     119       120   15,588    109     39.2
    
    Total-Cur  2,232     854       979             790     43.9
    5 day-avg    266     106       115             104     43.2
    Total-Est  5,956   2,335     2,589   17,041  2,134     43.5
    

    Historical March Sold and listing

    Year    Sold   Listing  S/L(%)
    2001    2,315   3,805   60.8
    2002    3,392   5,168   65.6
    2003    3,304   4,272   77.3
    2004    4,371   5,709   76.6
    2005    3,938   5,083   77.5
    2006    4,033   5,767   69.9
    2007    3,582   5,456   65.7
    2008    2,997   5,674   52.8
    2009    2,265   4,385   51.7
    2010    3,137   7,004   44.8
    2011    4,080   6,797   60.0
    
    Avg     3,401   5,375   63.3
    Median  3,392   5,456   65.6
    

    Current score: 21
  29. 53
  30. Anonymous Says: Reply to this comment

    @Anonymous:

    The Tyee gets most of its funding from unions affiliated with the BC Federation of Labour and works closely with the massive US Eco group the Tides Foundation, which has funneled tens of millions of dollars into groups against the oil sands and, incidentally, helped fund the mayoral campaign of Gregor Robertson.

    It may be a useful article but it always helps to know where they’re coming from.

    Current score: 8
  31. 52
  32. Dougie Park Troll Says: Reply to this comment

    @jumpin in: That house may look comparatively cheap but I bet it sells within the week.

    Current score: 1
  33. 51
  34. specuskeptic specuskeptic Says: Reply to this comment

    CBC clip on Brocki’s Tyee story….
    http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/story/2012/03/12/bc-vancouver-housing-cost-priced-out.html

    Current score: 5

Pages: [2] 1 » Show All

Leave a Reply

Wordpress theme by Abhishek Tripathi of Mediawick Digital Solutions