494 Comments
newest
oldest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
trackback

[…] Mortgage rules to blame […]

trackback

[…] not just Vancouver, sales are falling across the nation marking the first March decline since the […]

southseacompany
southseacompany
1 year ago

“In midst of slow home sales, B.C. Real Estate Association shines spotlight on impact of tighter mortgage rules”, Georgia Straight

https://www.straight.com/news/1228241/midst-slow-home-sales-bc-real-estate-association-puts-spotlight-impact-tighter-mortgage

“And once again, the BCREA has pointed the finger at a federal mortgage policy as a major contributing factor. The B-20 test, introduced last year by the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions, requires lenders to test a borrower’s ability to repay a mortgage if interest rates were 200 basis points above the agreed-upon rate.”

Oracle
Oracle
1 year ago

Trudeau government plans to increase foreign student intake. Presently at 600,000.

To what? A million??

Canada is for Canadians
Canada is for Canadians
1 year ago

“Almost exactly two years ago, at the peak of the Vancouver housing bubble which was the result of an unprecedented money-laundering funds flow by Chinese oligarchs and tycoons into the Western Canadian real estate market”.

“Meanwhile, business as usual continues as China’s wealthiest can’t wait to transfer their savings offshore, even as Beijing, now facing its first current account deficit in modern history, is desperate to open up its own corrupt and crony capital markets to yield-starved foreign investors who in turn will make sure that Ding Chen ends up buying many more Bugattis before he too is mysteriously found deceased of a “heroin overdose” in the boot of some (super)car himself.”

Ya gotta love reading ZH if just for the literary content …

StupidityCheck
StupidityCheck
1 year ago

Tell me again how you don’t immerse yourself in extreme right-wing propaganda…

Bubble
Bubble
1 year ago

Welcome to Cedar Walk by Polygon, a picturesque and walkable parkside community steps from an abundance of shops and services. Nestled at the gateway to the UBC campus, Cedar Walk is surrounded by a stunning natural setting and all that a great university has to offer. Great elementary and secondary schools are also nearby.
Not sure who is buying these new condos at UBC, priced $1200 /square foot. Many of them sold lately.
For example:
2019-Mar-22 Listed $1,158,800 MLS # R2352398

Shut It Down Already (original)
Shut It Down Already (original)
1 year ago
Reply to  Bubble

They all sold at exactly asking price, so isn’t this just the sales being registered from completion of the building?

southseacompany
southseacompany
1 year ago

“Big Housing Bust to Come”, Nasdaq

https://www.nasdaq.com/article/big-housing-bust-to-come-cm1128112

“How does a big global housing meltdown sound? Crappy. Well, that is exactly one of the things that the IMF is currently warning investors about. Americans will already be well aware of the several month downturn in real estate, but what is likely much less well understood is that many markets around the world, including emerging markets, look at risk of a major housing bust. One of the big worries of the IMF is that a real estate downturn will spark a banking crisis in overseas markets that could then bubble over to the rest of the world.”

southseacompany
southseacompany
1 year ago

“Sovereign Debt, Slowing Growth, and a Housing Bust Top the IMF’s Worry List”, Barron’s

https://www.barrons.com/articles/sovereign-debt-slowing-growth-and-a-housing-bust-top-the-imfs-worry-list-51554987600

“Boom-bust patterns in house prices preceded more than two-thirds of the nearly 50 systemic banking crises in recent decades. In 30% of advanced and emerging markets, housing prices are at risk for declines at a similar magnitude to 2007 in the U.S.”

southseacompany
southseacompany
1 year ago

“The housing bust and why it’s likely to continue”, ABC Australia

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-04-15/why-the-housing-bust-is-likely-to-continue/11002296

“Australian housing prices have been unwinding at a serious clip now for close to a year and a half, led by the cities that kicked off the boom, Sydney and Melbourne.”

“The problem now is that the fundamentals driving the slide cannot easily be altered. An interest rate cut may ease the pain but won’t cure the affliction. That’s because the housing market is being undermined by two potent forces; much tighter credit conditions and a looming supply glut.”

southseacompany
southseacompany
1 year ago

“Canadian home sales fall for sixth month in first March decline since the recession”, Financial Post

https://business.financialpost.com/real-estate/canada-home-prices-drop-in-march-for-sixth-straight-month-teranet

“Canada’s once-hot housing market has softened since the start of last year, as tighter mortgage rules and five interest rate hikes from the Bank of Canada since July 2017 have curbed buyer spending power.”

southseacompany
southseacompany
1 year ago

“Edmonton home sales and selling prices suffer five-year March lows, first quarter real estate statistics show”, Edmonton Journal

https://edmontonjournal.com/business/real-estate/how-low-can-you-go-edmonton-house-prices-dip-in-first-quarter-of-2019

““We were expecting the market to be moving but it continues to be slow, a lot of which is driven by external factors that are beyond our control where federal policy is continuing to have a negative effect in Alberta,” association chairman Michael Brodrick said Wednesday.”

Shut It Down Already (original)
Shut It Down Already (original)
1 year ago

All the foreign buyers left Edmonton, too!

southseacompany
southseacompany
1 year ago

“Why house prices are unlikely to rise any time soon”, MacLeans’s

https://www.macleans.ca/economy/realestateeconomy/canada-real-estate-market-spring-outlook/

“Last January, the government imposed a new mortgage stress test. Uninsured borrowers must now qualify at the Bank of Canada’s five-year benchmark rate, or at their current rate plus an additional two per cent. The changes had an instant effect on sales, one that is likely to continue this spring. Prices in February fell for Vancouver, Edmonton and Calgary, marking Calgary’s 10th month of drops, with Edmonton in negative territory since the summer of 2017. “

Best place on meth
Best place on meth
1 year ago

3867 INVERNESS ST, 1.450, 1.328, 1.120, -23%

435 37TH AVE E, 1.546, 1.449, 1.189, -23%

436 55TH AVE E, 1.350, 1.050, 950K, -30%

8367 VICTORIA DR, 1.092, 999K, 970K, -11%

4015 BOUNDARY RD, 1.426, 1.500, 1.199, -16%

1316 20TH AVE E, 1.562, 1.499, 1.300, -17%

YVR
YVR
1 year ago

Engineers of the Soul: Ideology in Xi Jinping’s China by John Garnaut

John Garnaut, one of the top journalists covering China before he joined the Australian government, first as a speech writer for Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull and then as a China policy advisor.

The challenge for us is that Xi’s project of total ideological control does not stop at China’s borders. It is packaged to travel with Chinese students, tourists, migrants and especially money. It flows through the channels of the Chinese language internet, pushes into all the world’s major media and cultural spaces and generally keeps pace with and even anticipates China’s increasingly global interests.

https://sinocism.com/p/engineers-of-the-soul-ideology-in

Best place on meth
Best place on meth
1 year ago

5028 PINE CRES, 2018 assessment 3.405, listed 2.980, sold 2.840, -17% to assessed value.

642 52ND AVE W, 2.726, 2.750, 2.400, -12%

1826 12 AVE W, 2.536, 2.679, 1.875, -26%

6091 WILLOW ST, 3.088, 2.988, 2.580, -16%

4411 4TH AVE W, 7.149, 6.599, 5.300, -26% (-37% from 2017 assessed)

6453 MACDONALD ST, 3.878, 3.788, 3.100, -20%

Best place on meth
Best place on meth
1 year ago

Forgot this one:

1849 30TH AVE W, 3.756, 2.998, 2.800, -25%

Best place on meth
Best place on meth
1 year ago

It’s the spring edition of “WEAR EEBEE?”

https://mailchi.mp/leg/sh95sy9e8h?e=e46d1d4b50

Doomcouver
Doomcouver
1 year ago

On a side note, is it weird that I’m looking forward to Peter German’s newest money laundering report more than the new Avengers movie?

Best place on meth
Best place on meth
1 year ago
Reply to  Doomcouver

No, not weird.

I’m fucking sick of all the superhero/comic book/animated shit in theaters all the time now.

Oracle
Oracle
1 year ago

It’s all by one company now. Disney now owns Marvel who own basically alll the superheroes including X men.

Batman, Superman, WW the other side.

Bubble
Bubble
1 year ago

March 2019 Market Insights – Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver
https://youtu.be/XMuPT8fCkQc

Do you agree with her statement (too many policy changes only put buyer on the sideline temporarily).

Doomcouver
Doomcouver
1 year ago
Reply to  Bubble

Totally disagree. Yes the new policies are having an effect, but they’re just amplifying weakness that was starting to creep in before the policy changes anyways. These multi-decade lows on sales volumes are a measurement of buyer fear, and I feel it’s enough fear that the buyers aren’t going to come back in time to prop up the extremely precarious valuations. Once some horror stories from highly motivated sellers begin to permeate market sentiment, there will be a self-perpetuating downward spiral that won’t stop we hit some sort of utilitarian valuations in most metros. The only hope for sellers is if the market stays inflated long enough that buyers assume the money-printing machine still works and the FOMO’s come back in. It’s not a very likely outcome this late in the credit cycle however.

Oracle
Oracle
1 year ago
Reply to  Doomcouver

Can’t believe I’m going to agree with you here.

The psychology could take this market down. Pressure your MLAs to keep up the pressure. Don’t let up.

franko
franko
1 year ago
Reply to  Bubble

@Bubble I guess the REBGV had to settle for Ashley Smith for that bit of propaganda because the y couldn’t find Bagdad Bob. Certainly intended for the dumb of the dumbest. I mean, lets look at the big picture before we stray entirely from reality: There are clear indications that the turning of the RE tide is a global thing…Australia, the UK, Europe, and warnings emerging in the US. HAM which had driven our bubble to the utmost limits of insanity is not only DEAD, but is now scrambling to get the hell out. Desperate boomers will be the next to cash out while they still can. Locals who bought at the peak are buried in debt and stretched to the limit. Local incomes are a fraction of what would be required support a million$ mortgage. Oh, and what about… Read more »

YVR
YVR
1 year ago
Reply to  Bubble

“Do you agree with her statement (too many policy changes only put buyer on the sideline temporarily).”

I agree with this statement. Most “buyers” will eventually buy but at a fraction of the price.

Oracle
Oracle
1 year ago

16,000 total inventory by end of April is what’s needed.

Best place on meth
Best place on meth
1 year ago
Reply to  Oracle

Why?

YVR
YVR
1 year ago

More inventory is obviously better. Once we hit 20000 there is no turning back. Next spring for we should be there.

Doomcouver
Doomcouver
1 year ago
Reply to  YVR

14,342 TI on Friday. So for 16k we’d need 1,648 more listings. 16 days left in April means an average of 103 more listings than solds+expiries per day. Not going to happen at current pace, but if the fabled “rush to the exits” starts before the end of month then anything is possible.

Simple Solution
Simple Solution
1 year ago
Reply to  Oracle

Dad, are you still expecting this little dip in prices to reverse?

Should I buy now or be priced out forever???

VanRant
VanRant
1 year ago

CBC talks about how money laundering through Vancouver Real Estates
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t-wm-rI0uho
We need a public inquiry now.

YVR
YVR
1 year ago
Reply to  VanRant

We need police investigations and charges laid. Do you think HAM cares about political and finger pointing spin?

Laibach
Laibach
1 year ago
Reply to  YVR

Certainly not, they have no sense of shame or social responsibility whatsoever.

Laibach
Laibach
1 year ago

Cry me a fucking river…

Developer admits he’s ‘desperate’ as multimillion-dollar West Vancouver home prices tumble

https://www.thestar.com/vancouver/2019/04/11/developer-admits-hes-desperate-as-multimillion-dollar-west-vancouver-home-prices-tumble.html

Best place on meth
Best place on meth
1 year ago
Reply to  Laibach

“Geller, who has worked in the real estate industry for 45 years, said this market is the worst he’s ever seen — and that includes downturns in the early 1980s and the 2008 financial crisis.
Between June 2015 and June 2016, home prices in West Vancouver and Vancouver’s westside rose by 37.8 and 36.4 per cent, respectively…….
Soprovich said buyers from Mainland China were a big presence in the West Vancouver market in 2015 and 2016, but tighter capital flow restrictions brought in by the Chinese government, and the decision to introduce the foreign buyer tax and then increase it from 15 to 20 per cent, have basically “put the brakes on foreign investors.”

Canada is for Canadians
Canada is for Canadians
1 year ago

Gelled and his ilk can’t be too smart if they thought the house party would’ve continued indefinitely. This Chinese money would be the most fickle of any.

Canada is for Canadians
Canada is for Canadians
1 year ago

Geller still expects to America’s a 5% profit so he’s not exactly losing his shirt. And soprovich says people are now buying houses to actually live in. What a concept. The NDP has been successful in reigning in this crazy housing market.

Canada is for Canadians
Canada is for Canadians
1 year ago

Make a 5% profit. spell check malfunction.

Dave
1 year ago

Doubt it. He’s going to lose IMO.

YVR
YVR
1 year ago
Reply to  Dave

Yup the places are not selling at the 5% profit price. Clearly he will have to cut prices by more than that to sell. More the longer he waits.

Simple Solution
Simple Solution
1 year ago
Reply to  YVR

He should just rent them while he waits! Real estate always cash flows doesn’t it?

YVR
YVR
1 year ago

“The NDP has been successful in reigning in this crazy housing market”

Nothing to do with the NDP other than the token 5% increase of the foreign buyer tax.

Soprovich said buyers from Mainland China were a big presence in the West Vancouver market in 2015 and 2016, but tighter capital flow restrictions brought in by the Chinese government, and the decision to introduce the foreign buyer tax and then increase it from 15 to 20 per cent

Royce McC
Royce McC
1 year ago

On the one hand, we have this guy saying “this market is the worst he’s ever seen — and that includes downturns in the early 1980s and the 2008 financial crisis.”

On the other hand we have price plots like the one shown in this article that was posted here just a little while ago, which show how we’ve barely begun reversing the future-harming madness of the last 15 years:
https://wolfstreet.com/2019/04/12/the-most-splendid-housing-bubbles-in-canada-deflate-march-update/

I swear, people like Geller need that eyes-propped-open Clockwork Orange treatment, watching videos of price plots, stories of young people abandoning the region, etc.

He could end up feeling ill every time he tried to say the words “world class” or “hard earned equity”, or if he tried referring to young people being the ones who are acting “entitled”.

Spec
1 year ago
Reply to  Laibach

Geller makes the world a worse place… and he should feel bad.

YVR
YVR
1 year ago
Reply to  Spec

People like Geller will help prices correct. He is one of the “must sell” sellers who will have to take what ever the market will pay. Probably leveraged to the tits with a high interest private lender. He was late to the game and will help with the first big leg down this spring.

Laibach
Laibach
1 year ago

A reminder that favorite locust “students” didn’t throw a towel yet. How adorable and inspiring.

“Chinese tycoon’s son complains about B.C. taxes on purchase of $5M supercar”

https://www.ctvnews.ca/mobile/canada/chinese-tycoon-s-son-complains-about-b-c-taxes-on-purchase-of-5m-supercar-1.4378611

Laibach
Laibach
1 year ago
Reply to  Laibach

China’s Union Pay credit cards have been the subject of increasing scrutiny as a conduit for money out of the mainland. China has an annual cash export limit of US$50,000, and Union Pay says it enforces an annual overseas cash withdrawal limit of 100,000 yuan (US$14,880).

https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/3005989/chinese-tycoons-son-buys-us38million-bugatti-chiron-vancouver

Best place on meth
Best place on meth
1 year ago
Reply to  Laibach

The son of the duck farmer is outraged that he has to pay any taxes at all in our country.

I wonder what he’s paying for insurance?

It should be at least 1.5 million a year considering he’s going to crash the car in the very near future.

Canada is for Canadians
Canada is for Canadians
1 year ago

I hope ICBC won’t insure that thing.

Spec
1 year ago

Summary: “When sales were low in February, people blamed the snow. People thought that spring would be different. March did bring a warmest day in 123 years, and was one of the driest on record, but still real estate sales remained very cold. The REBGV blames government intervention, but as I discussed in a previous blog post, this is just part of the equation. We are very late in a credit cycle, and it will probably unfold as it has in other credit cycles. ”

Full post here: https://canreinvest.wordpress.com/2019/04/13/down-down-vancouver-real-estate-trend-in-march/

April just may end up adding 2K to inventory…..

Best place on meth
Best place on meth
1 year ago
Reply to  Spec

Sorry everyone, but the spring market has been cancelled this year!

Drive safely!

Spec
1 year ago

What I’m really digging is that trend line that is parallel to my favourite year – 2008. (Thinking to myself while muttering “thou shall not extrapolate, thou shall not extrapolate, thou shall not extrapolate”)

YVR
YVR
1 year ago

Actually this is the spring market. Get used to it for about 5 to 10 years.

Big Bear
Big Bear
1 year ago
Canada is for Canadians
Canada is for Canadians
1 year ago
Reply to  Big Bear

Unlikely.

Laibach
Laibach
1 year ago
Best place on meth
Best place on meth
1 year ago
Reply to  Laibach

Between 2002 and 2018, San Francisco prices increased 120% while Vancouver prices increased 320%.

I wonder why such a massive discrepancy.

Tougher money laundering laws in the US as opposed to our non existent ones?

YVR
YVR
1 year ago

Yes but San Francisco does not have the high paying tech jobs like Hootsuite. Oh wait Hootsuite doesn’t pay its workers I forgot. We do have more mountains.

Shut It Down Already (original)
Shut It Down Already (original)
1 year ago
Reply to  YVR

Hootsuite pays its workers. There was a period when they had unpaid internships.

Shut It Down Already (original)
Shut It Down Already (original)
1 year ago

It’s because San Francisco is a sanctuary city and Vancouver isn’t, of course.

Winnipeg is also up there because of all the foreign buyers and convenient flights to China.

Best place on meth
Best place on meth
1 year ago

Winnipeg is up where?

What is the cost of a house in Winnipeg compared to Vancouver?

Shut It Down Already (original)
Shut It Down Already (original)
1 year ago

You clearly didn’t read the link.

Selective Memory
Selective Memory
1 year ago

“I wonder why such a massive discrepancy.”

Perhaps because San Francisco had a proper housing crash in 2008, while Vancouver did not?

paulb
paulb
1 year ago

New
157
Price Change
92
Sold
78
TI:14352

http://www.clivestevepaul.com